Slop TVNewsLatest
Business

OpenAI must face Canadian publishers' copyright suit in Ontario

The Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI's bid to move the case south, leaving Canada's first suit over using news to train generative AI in an Ontario courtroom.

Illustration: OpenAI must face Canadian publishers' copyright suit in Ontario
Illustration: SLOP TV News. Logos are trademarks of their owners.

Key takeaways

  • The Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI's appeal on November 13, 2026 in Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc., 2026 ONCA 814, keeping a copyright suit by Canadian news publishers in Ontario.
  • A unanimous panel of Justices Miller, Favreau and Rahman upheld Justice Jessica Kimmel's November 7, 2025 ruling that Ontario has jurisdiction and a real and substantial connection to the alleged breaches.
  • The court ordered OpenAI to pay $100,000 in appeal costs, an amount agreed among the parties.
  • The ruling decides only where the case is heard; no court has found that OpenAI infringed any work.

OpenAI must defend a copyright suit brought by Canada's largest news publishers in Ontario, after the province's Court of Appeal dismissed the company's bid to move the case to the United States. In reasons dated November 13, 2026, a unanimous panel of Justices Miller, Favreau and Rahman upheld the lower court's refusal to set aside service of the claim and ordered OpenAI to pay $100,000 in appeal costs, an amount agreed among the parties.

The plaintiffs are Toronto Star Newspapers, Metroland Media Group, Postmedia Network, PMO Maritimes, The Globe and Mail, Canadian Press Enterprises and CBC/Société Radio-Canada. They allege OpenAI breached the Copyright Act and their websites' terms of use, and was unjustly enriched, by crawling and scraping their journalism to train the large language models that power ChatGPT and reproducing that content for commercial use.

OpenAI, a group of Delaware corporations served with the claim outside Ontario, argued the alleged conduct fell outside the reach of Canadian law and that the dispute belonged in a U.S. courtroom. Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice rejected that argument on November 7, 2025, holding the court had both subject-matter and personal jurisdiction over six of the OpenAI entities, and that there was a good arguable case for a real and substantial connection to Ontario. She granted the motion for four defendants not shown to be involved in the business operations at issue.

On appeal, OpenAI renewed its jurisdictional challenge and added that the United States was a clearly more appropriate forum. Justice B.W. Miller applied the test from the Supreme Court of Canada's 2012 Club Resorts Ltd. v. Van Breda decision. The motion judge had found a good arguable case that at least one presumptive connecting factor was present: some OpenAI entities carry on business in Ontario, some of the alleged wrongful acts were committed there, and the parent companies were unjustly enriched by conduct in Ontario. The panel found no reviewable error in any of those findings.

The court also rejected OpenAI's territorial argument. The motion judge held that a dispute about the reach of the Copyright Act is a question for a motion on the pleadings, not a jurisdictional motion, and that OpenAI could not raise it without submitting to the court's jurisdiction. The panel agreed, and noted the case raised three connecting factors, so the appeal would have failed even if OpenAI had won on the copyright point alone.

On forum, the panel upheld the finding that Ontario is the more appropriate, suitable and convenient forum. As The Canadian Press reported, the decision said OpenAI filed no evidence that a judgment in Canada would conflict with existing United States law, which would complicate enforcement. The report quotes the judge's finding that "the fair and efficient working of the Canadian legal system favoured allowing Canadian authors to bring claims against foreign companies for breaches of Canadian laws."

Two limits bound what the ruling means. It settles where the case is heard, not whether OpenAI infringed anything: the publishers' claims are allegations in a statement of claim, and no court has ruled on their merits. OpenAI can still seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, which accepts a small share of the cases sent to it, as SI Agent News noted.

The publishers are not relying on this case alone. Earlier in 2026, Postmedia, Torstar, The Globe and Mail and The Canadian Press launched a separate suit against Anthropic, and a group including the Toronto Star, Condé Nast and McClatchy is suing the Canadian AI company Cohere. In the United States, copyright cases against AI companies date to 2023. News and cultural groups have asked the federal government to clarify how AI systems may use copyrighted work, and Ottawa has not signaled plans to update the Copyright Act.

For creators, the practical effect is jurisdictional. A Canadian court has held that a foreign AI developer earning revenue from Canadian users can be brought before Ontario judges, which gives Canadian rights holders a domestic route instead of a U.S. one. What that route produces depends on a trial that has not begun.

The case returns to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice for a hearing on the merits; no date is set.

Sources

  1. norma.lexum.com - the Court of Appeal's November 13, 2026 reasons (2026 ONCA 814): the disposition, the panel, the $100,000 costs and the Van Breda analysis
  2. canlii.org - the lower court's November 7, 2025 jurisdiction ruling (2025 ONSC 6217): the six-of-ten defendants finding and the forum non conveniens holding
  3. bnnbloomberg.ca - the Canadian Press report carried by BNN Bloomberg, November 13, 2026: the no-conflict-of-laws evidence, the quoted finding and the first-Canadian-case framing
  4. lapresse.ca - La Presse's November 13, 2026 report on the ruling and the separate Anthropic case
  5. torontotoday.ca - TorontoToday's Canadian Press report, November 14, 2026, with the Anthropic, Cohere and Ottawa context
  6. broadcastdialogue.com - Broadcast Dialogue's November 13, 2026 report and its costs figure
  7. siagentnews.com - the Supreme Court of Canada route after a dismissed appeal