Slop TVNewsLatest
Business

Warsaw court calls AI-cloned voice in an ad a deepfake

Judge Sylwia Wit vel Wilk ordered JFC Polska to remove the material, publish apologies on Facebook and Wirtualne Media, and pay 47,280 zlotys.

Illustration: Warsaw court calls AI-cloned voice in an ad a deepfake
Illustration: SLOP TV News. Logos are trademarks of their owners.

Key takeaways

  • The Warsaw Regional Court's intellectual property division ruled on November 13, 2026 that adverts using an AI-generated copy of voice actor Jarosław Łukomski's voice had the character of a deepfake.
  • Judge Sylwia Wit vel Wilk ordered JFC Polska to delete every video carrying the generated voice, to stop using it, to publish apologies for 45 days on Facebook and 14 days on its website, and to pay 30,000 zlotys for harm and 17,280 zlotys for losses.
  • The court held that a voice is a protected personal good for every individual regardless of fame, and that the test is whether listeners could believe the words really came from the person imitated.
  • The ruling is not final, and JFC Polska says it wants settlement talks with Łukomski before deciding on further procedural steps.

The Warsaw Regional Court ruled on November 13 that advertisements using an AI-generated copy of voice actor Jarosław Łukomski's voice had the character of a deepfake, and ordered the advertiser, JFC Polska, to remove the material, publish apologies and pay damages.

The intellectual property division ordered JFC Polska, a maker of household sewage treatment systems, to delete every video containing the generated voice and not to use it again, according to RMF24, which reported the ruling the same afternoon. The company must publish an apology for 45 days on its Facebook page, for 14 days on its website and on the industry portal Wirtualne Media, and pay the costs of the case.

Rzeczpospolita reported the award as 30,000 zlotys with interest as compensation for the harm and 17,280 zlotys for Łukomski's losses, and gave the case file number as XXII GW 724/2025. Voiceover Herald put the two sums at about $7,500 and about $4,260. TVN24 reported the total as more than 47,000 zlotys.

Judge Sylwia Wit vel Wilk set out the test in her oral reasoning. The harm in a voice-cloning case, she said, lay in the generation of content the imitated person never spoke and that listeners might take as authentic, Rzeczpospolita reported. She said the type of content did not matter, nor whether it was positive, nor its quality, nor how many people heard it. What counted was whether a listener could believe the words came from the person imitated, which the court said could breach the right to privacy and to protection of one's image.

The court held that a voice is a protected personal good for every individual, regardless of popularity or professional recognition. It rejected the argument from Łukomski's lawyers that as one of Poland's most recognizable film narrators he carried a distinctively valuable premium voice, RMF24 reported. The judge said the case was the first dispute of its kind in the Polish courts, and that courts in Germany had issued similar rulings, according to TVN24.

A court-appointed expert found that from the perspective of an average listener the two voices were clearly and deceptively similar, RMF24 reported. The court also heard a graphic designer employed by JFC Polska who had worked on the adverts. To Their Credit reported that he testified he built advertising narrators from AI voice-model tools and samples from a voice library, then adjusted pace and vocal emotion, and that the campaign ran versions in Polish, Czech, Slovak and Hungarian.

The damages came in below what Łukomski sought. Of 50,000 zlotys requested for harm, the court awarded 30,000, and of more than 100,000 zlotys claimed for losses it awarded 17,280, citing doubts about how those losses were valued, Rzeczpospolita reported.

JFC Polska denied intending to infringe his rights. Its president, Mirosław Majewski, said the adverts used neither Łukomski's name nor his image, and the company said it had offered a settlement, Rzeczpospolita reported.

Łukomski has read foreign films for Polish television since 1983, among them war films, and reads the film news program Aktualności filmowe on Canal+, Voiceover Herald reported. He sued after hearing a voice like his in online advertising for home sewage treatment systems. He said he had not recorded the material, had not agreed to the campaign and had not been paid for it.

He told Polsat News that hearing the advert was "a shock, not a positive shock, but a kind of great bitterness," in a translation published by Voiceover Herald. After the verdict he told TVN24 that he hoped the precedent would in time find its way into Polish law.

To Their Credit reported that the ruling follows a March 2023 judgment of the Supreme Court of Poland, cited by the Polish Council of Legal Advisers, that treated a voice as an independent personal good forming part of a person's physical identity.

Damian Flisak, a legal adviser at the Warsaw firm Lubasz i Wspólnicy, told Rzeczpospolita that the ruling was a strong signal consistent with decisions in the European Union and elsewhere that treat a voice as a personal good. He said that if that line consolidates, legislators may conclude that personal-rights claims are enough and that no new statute is needed, and that the Danish draft rules barring realistic digital imitations of a voice or an appearance without consent would give artists more than a damages award does.

For creators working in dubbing and localization, the ruling turns on how an audience hears a performance. Tomasz Ejtminowicz, Łukomski's lawyer, told Rzeczpospolita that the court did not test whether the voice was a complete technical match, only whether an ordinary listener who knew Łukomski's voice would take it as his. Ejtminowicz read the judgment as holding that an advertiser cannot escape liability by saying it used outside tools, and that a person has to check what an AI system produces before it reaches the public. If that reading holds on appeal, a studio that licenses a synthetic voice, or a brand that buys one from a library, would need a record that the person consented.

The judgment is not final. Lawyers for JFC Polska told Rzeczpospolita it was too early to announce an appeal. Mateusz Krysiak of JFC Polska told TVN24 that both sides had declared readiness for settlement talks, that the company wanted to hold them, and that further procedural steps depended on the outcome.

The judgment is not final. JFC Polska says it wants settlement talks before deciding whether to appeal.

Sources

  1. rp.pl - case number XXII GW 724/2025, the judge's reasoning, the award breakdown, the defendant's denial, the expert comment
  2. tvn24.pl - the 47,000 zloty total, Łukomski's comments, JFC Polska's settlement statement, the apology wording
  3. rmf24.pl - Polish-language account: the ruling, the expert opinion, the orders, the voice-as-personal-good holding, the German precedents
  4. voiceoverherald.com - dollar conversions, Łukomski's career, the Polsat News quote, the dziennik.pl report on the defendant's first response
  5. totheircredit.com - the graphic designer's testimony, the four language versions, the March 2023 Supreme Court judgment, the sums sought